@Natalka we were watching the whole thing live and both DH and I figured it MUST be a Jimmy Kimmel prank, but even for him that would be a cruel prank. I credit Warren Beatty for pausing as long as he could, he saw Emma's name on the card, but sadly Faye Dunaway only saw the movie title under her name and blurted that out.
I'll just bet Faye was wondering why Warren was delaying like that....how foolish did she feel after?