I opened my account a year ago and in that time I redeemed for:
Big flyer (still to big for DD)
Ybike (DD still to small but soon)
Bubble train (saving for DD birthday so not sure how good)
Cozy coupe (awesome)
Toy Story bin (awesome)
Princess easel (waiting for DD bday)
Princess Desk (waiting on DD bday)
Crayola Tent (dd still to young but looks great)
Lego Bin (okay)
I am tempted to order the remote controlled car (need about 400 points) but I am always leery about redeeming all my points because then they always seem to put something I would have preferred more out.