What do you think trades should be worth 2.0

[angel_2011]

I wouldn't value the Pepsi at more than 1$ each since that's how much they go on sale for here. I have no idea how much Baboo goes on sale for but I'd say 1 Baboo sale price x2 (because it's an fpc) = Pepsi coupon value Make sense ?

thanks! I was offered 3 Pepsi B1G1 for 2 of the baboo fpcs - which did seem a bit low, but i wanted to be fair to myself and the other party as well - which is why i posted in here.

[Tbites]

thanks! I was offered 3 Pepsi B1G1 for 2 of the baboo fpcs - which did seem a bit low, but i wanted to be fair to myself and the other party as well - which is why i posted in here.

Like I said no idea how much Baboo is... but that sounds awfully low

[MomOfOne79]

To the OP, thanks for posting this!! I never really knew how people 'value' their coupons.

[momgoneawol]

Just want to run this by my experts

I am trading:
3 X FPC Sunlight ($9.15 max each)
3 X FPC Tetley tea ($5.99 max each)
4 X FPC Eggos ($3.49 max each)
1 X FPC Johnson cleaning product (max $7)
1 X FPC Glade Expressions (no max value stated)

and this is what I was offered for everything:
$ jello pudding, gel or mousse snacks wub2 = upc 05533956 exp dec 31, 2012
x2 1$ special k cracker chips 113g = upc 71194950 exp aug 10, 2012
x2 1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004258 exp aug 24, 2012
x2 1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004000 exp oct 15, 2012
x2 1$ colgate 360 optic white toothbrush = upc 80003950 exp oct 15, 2012
1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004136 exp nov 30, 2012
x2 1$ oral b manual toothbrush = upc 63763036 exp aug 31, 2012

I declined & told this trader that wasn't anywhere near a fair trade.
I was told I was being greedy & FPCs should be traded 1:1 with regular coupons for the amount they are worth

Wow that is no way close to fair. Maybe for ONE of the sunlight FPC if you really needed the coupons offered but for all of them I don't think so. For FPC I would want at least an equal amount in regular cents off coupons. $5.00 FPC for at least $5.00 in coupons that are say .50 cents off an item.

The right trade will come along.

[couponer2]

Thank you I was searching for this post I wish it was a sticky

[julesie-pie]

nvm....

[K8's Fate]

[lillygirl]

[smartshopper888]

bookmarked

[fitzgirl]

Just want to run this by my experts

I am trading:
3 X FPC Sunlight ($9.15 max each)
3 X FPC Tetley tea ($5.99 max each)
4 X FPC Eggos ($3.49 max each)
1 X FPC Johnson cleaning product (max $7)
1 X FPC Glade Expressions (no max value stated)

and this is what I was offered for everything:
$ jello pudding, gel or mousse snacks wub2 = upc 05533956 exp dec 31, 2012
x2 1$ special k cracker chips 113g = upc 71194950 exp aug 10, 2012
x2 1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004258 exp aug 24, 2012
x2 1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004000 exp oct 15, 2012
x2 1$ colgate 360 optic white toothbrush = upc 80003950 exp oct 15, 2012
1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004136 exp nov 30, 2012
x2 1$ oral b manual toothbrush = upc 63763036 exp aug 31, 2012

I declined & told this trader that wasn't anywhere near a fair trade.
I was told I was being greedy & FPCs should be traded 1:1 with regular coupons for the amount they are worth

ErinsMom, you were not greedy. I don't think any fair trader would have accepted that offer. Especially when you didn't even have tp on your wl. That is just crazy!

[DolceBella]

Just want to run this by my experts

I am trading:
3 X FPC Sunlight ($9.15 max each)
3 X FPC Tetley tea ($5.99 max each)
4 X FPC Eggos ($3.49 max each)
1 X FPC Johnson cleaning product (max $7)
1 X FPC Glade Expressions (no max value stated)

and this is what I was offered for everything:
$ jello pudding, gel or mousse snacks wub2 = upc 05533956 exp dec 31, 2012
x2 1$ special k cracker chips 113g = upc 71194950 exp aug 10, 2012
x2 1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004258 exp aug 24, 2012
x2 1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004000 exp oct 15, 2012
x2 1$ colgate 360 optic white toothbrush = upc 80003950 exp oct 15, 2012
1$ colgate optic white toothpaste = upc 80004136 exp nov 30, 2012
x2 1$ oral b manual toothbrush = upc 63763036 exp aug 31, 2012

I declined & told this trader that wasn't anywhere near a fair trade.
I was told I was being greedy & FPCs should be traded 1:1 with regular coupons for the amount they are worth

WOW You definitely weren't being greedy. That offer is kind of ridiculous. I'm not a trader that believe in everything being $ for $, but it should at least be fair for both sides. That trade would be far from fair for you

[julesie-pie]

what is a disney movie pin worth? I didnt see it on the first page.

[FallenPixels]

I have personally traded FPCs 1:1 for a regular coupon I really wanted since it was hard to find and of much more use to me than Baboo but firstly, that was my choice and secondly, the offer above isnt even 1:1, its not even $1 per coupon when most are $5 worth

No idea on the PIN Julesie, to get the PINs on the first page, we signed up to stuff and looked at the value of the 'best value' prize that people would actually use/buy and used it as a FPC (or GC if it was one) and valued it from there

So if it takes 10 pins to get something worth $15, each one is $1.50 FPC etc

[2shopmom]

So if it takes 10 pins to get something worth $15, each one is $1.50 FPC etc

What about an M&M's pouch top? To buy the item is 2.00 at WM. I'd like some input on this one, thanks.

[FallenPixels]

You go by what you get for them, not the cost to buy them (unless you are sending me the whole yummy bag of candy bc otherwise you got to enjoy them)

By trading for the pouchtop I get the prize not the candy, so price of movie ticket divided by number of pouchtops needed = trade value as FPC