AGH!! But I wanted another t-shirt!!!

I just went online to redeem for the Free Reebok PlayDry T-shirt. I had the pins but because I heard so many people complaining about the size I thought I would wait to receive my original shirts I ordered (one for myself and one for hubby) and then I would order again depending how they fit.
Well, I just received them yesterday and they fit perfectly. I went online to find out:
Sorry, this offer is no longer available.

Unfortunately, due to the popularity of this offer, our supply of Reebok PlayDry™ T-Shirts has been exhausted (click here for full offer details). Thank you for your interest.

I am so mad!!! Arggh!!!

I just got that too and I have 4 pins left! I emailed post as the pins were good until August... Haven't heard back yet though.

I emailed them too but I guess they will say package states "while quantities/supply last" but I find they should of made pins/packages same to their number of shirts
Why provide more pins when you can't redeem it after all?

That really sucks!!

Oh darnit!

Thanks for the heads up though. I do appreciate knowing that. I was kinda half thinking I might go buy a couple more boxes of cereal so that I could order a larger size shirt. It's funny you posted it today because I had this mind flash while I was walking tonight.

Guess I'll scrap that plan...

They can't make the number of pins equal to the shirts because not everyone redeems them and they'll be left with too much stock.

It's better for the company to have too many pins and not enough shirts than the other way around.

Sorry that you missed out on the promo. Maybe they will figure out something as a substitute later on.

So not cool! That happened to me last year when Cheerios had the beach towel promo.
Oh well, there's always another promo.

Yeah I was pretty bummed too when I saw the offer is no longer available message. I don't know how that could happen but oh well, I guess. Right?

yea theyve been out for over a month.
I tried to redeem my pin in the beginning of may and they were already all sold out :(