We haven't ever had a problem with the toilet paper, but then again, we really dislike the Charmins and such of the world - the really thick TP. Clogs up our pipes and such terribly. Our usual brand is Royale, which may be a bit softer, but is just as thin as the Satin Soft in reality.
Haven't tried the paper towel yet, but we only use paper towel for cooking (ie: bacon or deep fried items) and cooking messes, so roughness is fine.
Anyone tried the facial tissue?