The Official and ONLY Place to Discuss Negative Trade Experiences + Trade Blacklist

[annedougherty]

Okay...no envie from Etown and no communication since June 30th when she said she was mailing my envie to me expresspost post after it came back to her due to insufficient postage after our initial trade in May = Negative Feedback.

[ccandth]

just started trading and IT'S AMAZING. how great is it to get extra coupons come in the mail. had nothing but great experiences so far

[Cia]

well....left my first negative rating today.
I was on blewbyyou's #17 train, which started May 21st. I never received an envie from lilkaiser. She seems to be MIA, her wall is full of messages, people asking is she/he "got my envie" I hope lilkaiser will be blacklisted. Thank goodness the good people out weigh the bad on SC.

[Cia]

...also just got my first negative rating, in retaliation to a neg I left for lilkaiser. I have pm'd Sally with the details....now I wait.

[KrazE]

...also just got my first negative rating, in retaliation to a neg I left for lilkaiser. I have pm'd Sally with the details....now I wait.

Now that is just plain rude, isn't there some sort of rule about retaliation ratings?

[missidj]

well....left my first negative rating today.
I was on blewbyyou's #17 train, which started May 21st. I never received an envie from lilkaiser. She seems to be MIA, her wall is full of messages, people asking is she/he "got my envie" I hope lilkaiser will be blacklisted. Thank goodness the good people out weigh the bad on SC.

Was this a regular train or VWT? If this was a regular train then your not supposed to leave feedback for other riders only the conductor. It's only on VWT trains that you leave feedback for other riders. Check out the sticky in the trains section "How to Rate Regular Trains"

[Cia]

Now that is just plain rude, isn't there some sort of rule about retaliation ratings?

I think it's rude too. Not sure if there is a rule about that type of feedback or not, I will have to wait and see what Sally thinks.

[Cia]

Was this a regular train or VWT? If this was a regular train then your not supposed to leave feedback for other riders only the conductor. It's only on VWT trains that you leave feedback for other riders. Check out the sticky in the trains section "How to Rate Regular Trains"

No, it was not a regular train, I have been a passenger on many of them, and also conducted a couple of my own.
This was a little different: Each rider was to send their envie with coupons and also include in that envie, another envie with your wishlist coupons written on it. On to the next rider and so on, finally you are to get your envie back with either your wishlist coupons or a stamp to compensate. A combo train, with wishlist coupons, and a regular train. Not really sure what the official name is for that type of train.
I never received an envie from the rider before me. The entire train stopped at her. From myself onto the conductor all went well, it stopped dead at lilkaiser.

[PinkLincoln]

I've recently asked Sally about this.

She advised me retaliation negative ratings are not allowed.

[missidj]

No, it was not a regular train, I have been a passenger on many of them, and also conducted a couple of my own.
This was a little different: Each rider was to send their envie with coupons and also include in that envie, another envie with your wishlist coupons written on it. On to the next rider and so on, finally you are to get your envie back with either your wishlist coupons or a stamp to compensate. A combo train, with wishlist coupons, and a regular train. Not really sure what the official name is for that type of train.
I never received an envie from the rider before me. The entire train stopped at her. From myself onto the conductor all went well, it stopped dead at lilkaiser.

I see. Not really sure what kind that train would fall under, kind of a VWt but kind of small regular trains too. I'm sure it will all get straightened out for you

[KrazE]

Interesting coincidence on the visitor messages for the same person...

[Cia]

I see. Not really sure what kind that train would fall under, kind of a VWt but kind of small regular trains too. I'm sure it will all get straightened out for you

It is kinda of a "grey area" as trains go, as to what type it is. It would have been awesome if it worked out. I too hope that it will get straightened out, it does not seen right for me to get a negative when I have fulfilled my obligation to the train.

[Cia]

Interesting coincidence on the visitor messages for the same person...

I thought so too. I do not know the end results of those messages or the neutral rating she was also given, so she may have worked it out with the others.

[Cia]

I've recently asked Sally about this.

She advised me retaliation negative ratings are not allowed.

Glad to hear that!

[Sally888]

Yes, negative retaliation negs are NOT allowed, and the users feedback will be removed, if they do it 2x I will leave them a negative personally.

We need to act with some tact.

I may be sketchy to post in here this week, my husbands having nose surgery and today I was running around getting everything ready. He goes in tomorrow, so Ill be busy taking care of him I'm sure.