Question about trades

[Arielmac]

Ok ladies, some of you heard my newbie train story and since I don't want a remake of that nor do I want anyone taking advantage of my newbie status I am asking for your opinion here.

I posted in the trade forum:

FT

2x FPC Dempster's bagels EXP May 31 2012
2x 1$ off Dempter's Bagel EXP May 31 2012

1 Free Movie snack from Old El Paso EXP May 31, 2012
1 Free Movie Offer for a child from Cheerios EXP May 31 2012

LF

Smarties FPC
Oasis Juices
0.75 On any fresh products from Ziploc
1.50 on Any meat from Ziploc
0.75 On any bloc of cheese from Ziploc
1.50 Aero bubbles
Chapmans
3$ off Beneful dog foog (dry food)
Icoke Pins

This is what I got so far:

Answer 1:

Hi, interested in the following from your list
2x FPC Dempster's bagels EXP May 31 2012
2x 1$ off Dempter's Bagel EXP May 31 2012

Would offer these for trade
1x FPC Oasis juice
2x$1.50 wub2 Aero bubbles
2x$0.75 On any bloc of cheese from Ziploc

Answer 2:

hi there, Would you be interested in trading your 2 x Dempsters Bagels for 11 Icoke pins

And someone asking how many Pins I want.

I am tempted to go with the first one...

What do you guys think so far?

[Tbites]

Ariel, je veux t'aider... mais phhhhew les FPC je trouve ca melant Je connais pas les prix de vente (en special) des dempsters bagels ou du jus oasis (refrigerer ?, shelf = .99cents MAX a mon avis)... alors je ne peux pas t'aider a comparer leur valeur.


If the trader with offer #1 has a great rating and you like what she's offering.. I'd go with offer #1... but that's just me... hopefully someone else will chime in. Until then... Did you read this thread ?

[GeorgiaK]

Ariel, my first gut feeling was to go with offer 1, but that is because I don't collect the icoke pins.

Which one has more value to you? Which one will you use more? Do you do the icoke thing?

[Patty Smyth]

Personally I don't think either one is enough

[ccmp1974]

Personally I don't think either one is enough

x2

[Tbites]

Personally I don't think either one is enough

Really ? Offer #1 doesn't include the movies FPCs ...

Still learning

[ccmp1974]

I thought you need a few of the pins for the free movie tickets????

[Patty Smyth]

If ccmp1974 agrees with me then for once I am right!!! lol

Take a look in this thread maybe it will help.
http://forum.smartcanucks.ca/257044-...-2-0-a-canada/

[ccmp1974]

If the first offer asked for just 1 FPC it would be fare IMO but not for the 2.

[2010ontest]

I have no idea for Icoke pin, so would be tempted with offer 1
Because the cheese block is good on any brand and coupons offer are from the small WL (so wanted and not unuseful for you).

But I probably ask if the person could send some extra random coupon from his area (tearpad or other source). I do it sometime when the trade is just limit for me. This give me some english coupon to help other trade or offer the english coupon with a french only coupon in trade with people able to use french coupon if they have the english copy. And sometime I received great surprise

[Arielmac]

Ok, many opinions, me likes!

In that person's to trade list, they have 1 FPC that interest me and 1 BOGO that interest me. (Philly Cooking cream and Healthy choice) So How would you present this to her? Something along: Add the cooking cream FPC and we have a deal?

Patty, I did look at that thread, it helps a little but not enough lol

[Arielmac]

This is what I mean I don't want to be taken advantage of, latest offer I got: 4 Icoke pins for 2 FPC...

[IMLN]

I have no clue what Icoke is worth...but 4 HELL no!

[YOU AND ME]

This is what I mean I don't want to be taken advantage of, latest offer I got: 4 Icoke pins for 2 FPC...

You were taken

[Arielmac]

You were taken

I was not taken since I didn't accept but that was an example of what people are trying to do...