Yes, roasted. I was surprized when looking at all the recipes that the cooking time was so short, because I'm used to cooking beef roasts longer and lower temps to be tender.
To about 1/4 cup butter, I mixed in about eight cloves finely minced garlic, seasoning salt, thyme, chili powder - and slathered it all over the roast, most of it on top.
So it was in the oven at 425 degrees for 45 minutes, then rested for 15 tented with foil.
The middle was really rare - as it's supposed to be apparently - and it was fabulously delicious, especially with the sauce I made. Even the ends which were light pink to brown, were still very soft and flavourful.
The sauce I made was extra-hot horseradish, mayo, garlic powder, paprika, salt, pepper, sugar, and mustard. I didn't make it too hot, since I can't handle it too spicy, but just zingy enough. I had extra plain horseradish for my husband to add.

