What do you think trades should be worth 2.0

[luvfreestuff]

I have a $5 Indigo Kids promotional GC from Swiss Chalet. What is a fair value to trade this for?

[smartshopper888]

bookmarked

[Giving-Small]

Wow - that's really gone up then. Thanks for letting me know. And ccmp1974 too.

I had started just gifting them away a while ago.

I spoke to several ppl who trade for them in making the list and they seem to trade them higher than 'true value' so there is definitely a market for them

[bluzsuz]

who thinks that this is reasonable, am I not seeing things right?

I was interested in:
BOGO club house gravy product 02/15/12 x1
75 off international delight 03/12/12 x2 05/31/12 x3
50 off international delight 400or 473 ml 02/28/12 x1
40 off clover leaf smoked oysters or mussels 12/31/12 x3
1.00 off olivieri 12/31/12 x2
BOGO red rose Canadian breakfast exp 06/30/12 x1
75 off thinsations 02/22/12 x1
75 off summer fresh hummus or dip product 07/31/12 x 10
75 off tre stele cheese 03/31/12 x10
1.00 off tide 08/31/12 x1
1.00 wub2 old spice 08/31/12 x2
value of all items is 33.28

she asked for in return:
2 x ML Prime chicken =$10.00
$4.00 WM gc
$4 Tims GC
3 stamps

IMO she is wanting to trade me $34 of her for $105?

[annedougherty]

who thinks that this is reasonable, am I not seeing things right?

I was interested in:
BOGO club house gravy product 02/15/12 x1
75 off international delight 03/12/12 x2 05/31/12 x3
50 off international delight 400or 473 ml 02/28/12 x1
40 off clover leaf smoked oysters or mussels 12/31/12 x3
1.00 off olivieri 12/31/12 x2
BOGO red rose Canadian breakfast exp 06/30/12 x1
75 off thinsations 02/22/12 x1
75 off summer fresh hummus or dip product 07/31/12 x 10
75 off tre stele cheese 03/31/12 x10
1.00 off tide 08/31/12 x1
1.00 wub2 old spice 08/31/12 x2
value of all items is 33.28

she asked for in return:
2 x ML Prime chicken =$10.00
$4.00 WM gc
$4 Tims GC
3 stamps

IMO she is wanting to trade me $34 of her for $105?

Wow that's interesting!!!

[2010ontest]

who thinks that this is reasonable, am I not seeing things right?

I was interested in:
BOGO club house gravy product 02/15/12 x1
75 off international delight 03/12/12 x2 05/31/12 x3
50 off international delight 400or 473 ml 02/28/12 x1
40 off clover leaf smoked oysters or mussels 12/31/12 x3
1.00 off olivieri 12/31/12 x2
BOGO red rose Canadian breakfast exp 06/30/12 x1
75 off thinsations 02/22/12 x1
75 off summer fresh hummus or dip product 07/31/12 x 10
75 off tre stele cheese 03/31/12 x10
1.00 off tide 08/31/12 x1
1.00 wub2 old spice 08/31/12 x2
value of all items is 33.28

she asked for in return:
2 x ML Prime chicken =$10.00
$4.00 WM gc
$4 Tims GC
3 stamps

IMO she is wanting to trade me $34 of her for $105?

wow!

Disproportion is high here!!!

[bluzsuz]

she said she trades coupon $ value for even giftcard value all the time? what's the point of the coupon then?

[Ceren]

woow can't believe it!! I just did a trade with you and I think you are one of the people who offer fair amounts in return and you are very generous

she said she trades coupon $ value for even giftcard value all the time? what's the point of the coupon then?

[bluzsuz]

woow can't believe it!! I just did a trade with you and I think you are one of the people who offer fair amounts in return and you are very generous

Thanks - it kinda reminds of someones status I saw on here once about coupons being pieces of paper NOT gold.

[Taurus]

she said she trades coupon $ value for even giftcard value all the time? what's the point of the coupon then?

I don't think I believe that, unless she trades with newbies all the time who don't know any better!


Which is why I am THANKFUL for all the info on the site about trading & threads like this that make it easy to figure out what's fair. THANK-YOU to all the SCs who post their questions and opinions!

[leymi15]

In a trade of 2 x pull ups fpc & 4x huggies diapers fpc. What is fair to offer in a GC ? And if you offer $10 GC how
Many of Fpc you could receive in a trade ?

Thanks

[FallenPixels]

I don't think I believe that, unless she trades with newbies all the time who don't know any better!

Quite possibly, the poster should let Sally know who it is so she can keep an eye on their trades with newbies who may not know better, we often get a huge influx of new members tomorrow when people decide their resolution is to spend less

[FallenPixels]

In a trade of 2 x pull ups fpc & 4x huggies diapers fpc. What is fair to offer in a GC ? And if you offer $10 GC how
Many of Fpc you could receive in a trade ?

Thanks

Most people trade FPCs for 33-50% actual value in GCs (so not max value, what they sell for at a reasonable price) - I have no idea how much diapers cost... but whatever they sell for on sale, do 33-50% of that.

So $10 GC would get you $20-$30 (ish) in FPC

[leymi15]

Thanks

[momof5boys]

who thinks that this is reasonable, am I not seeing things right?

I was interested in:
BOGO club house gravy product 02/15/12 x1
75 off international delight 03/12/12 x2 05/31/12 x3
50 off international delight 400or 473 ml 02/28/12 x1
40 off clover leaf smoked oysters or mussels 12/31/12 x3
1.00 off olivieri 12/31/12 x2
BOGO red rose Canadian breakfast exp 06/30/12 x1
75 off thinsations 02/22/12 x1
75 off summer fresh hummus or dip product 07/31/12 x 10
75 off tre stele cheese 03/31/12 x10
1.00 off tide 08/31/12 x1
1.00 wub2 old spice 08/31/12 x2
value of all items is 33.28

she asked for in return:
2 x ML Prime chicken =$10.00
$4.00 WM gc
$4 Tims GC
3 stamps

IMO she is wanting to trade me $34 of her for $105?

Oh man...is this a joke? lol