The Official and ONLY Place to Discuss Negative Trade Experiences + Trade Blacklist

[stacymarie]

If you have a strong gut feeling like that, do not go through with it
If it sounds too good to be true - it probably is

Valiant, it is not about support, it is about being realistic. As I said, it is too early despite it being obvious to us given the number of trades. Sure you can contact sully but they came on this forum knowing they were going to rip people off, do you think they care? They don't hold the same values as the rest of us obviously

And coupons have no cash value, they are not transferrable etc, it says so right on the coupon - doing so is against the coupon rules. Sure you can argue that it is time spent collecting as ebay does but even then it is iffy

I usually ALWAYS go with my gut...not too sure why I didn't this time.
Based on the first pm that I received from them I am not too sure it was what they were thinking of doing from day one of joining... When I pmd for a trade I was told all the coupons were gone and they went really fast. Sully took a look at my trades list after that and said that they still had a few that they were saving for themselves but wanted items off my list. I think maybe Sulley realized what kind of profit they could make with having such a hot HV coupon for "trade" ... but maybe that's just me trying to see the "good" in the person but they gave into temptation...if that makes any sense.

[solosaver]

I sent a trade to Sully1234 early June...thought it was just delayed because of the strike...I sent 30 $5 WUB 3 gillette, for 4 kellogs FPCs.....obviously I got scammed as well as the rest of us.

[Cia]

On June 6th sulley1234 pm'd me asking about a trade for FPC's I had, for Kelloggs FPC of his/hers.

June 7th 4:56 pm. sulley1234 confirmed which 3 FPC of mine she wanted in trade for her FPC's, confirmed to me that there is no $ value or exp. date on the Kelloggs FPC. I replied with that I found that to be strange, and how did she get those "many" FPC she had.

June 7th 5:06 pm. sulley replied that FPC "came directly from Kelloggs and not that strange at all"

June 7th 5:07 pm sulley "I will send you a picture hold on"

June 7th 5:16 pm. sulley "no idea how to attach a photo, can I send it to your email"

June 7th 5:30 pm. sulley "if still interested send me your email & I'll send a photo of coupon.

At about 4:56 pm, on June 7th the hair on the back of my neck stood up, it's like my own special super power, would love a cape, but will have to settle for a hairy neck.
I did not reply to the last 4 pms from sulley. Something did not feel right from the start and as the pm's continued I felt that sulley was becoming a little too pushy for my liking.
I am truly sorry for the honest SC's who have been scammed by sulley1234 and all the other rotten people. It is hard to find honest people to trade with, and with the media attention to couponing it is bringing a whole new batch of rats into the open, from trades to trains.

[lady_arianna]

can we put the justdoit2008 person on the blacklist, as well as there other user name they use?

[Valiant]

I'm going to send Sulley1234 a postcard, not a letter, with some questions on the message part of the card. Lots of posties read these. Maybe they'll be alerted to keep Sulley's address under observation.

[Kyriakos]

I'm going to send Sulley1234 a postcard, not a letter, with some questions on the message part of the card. Lots of posties read these. Maybe they'll be alerted to keep Sulley's address under observation.

No postal worker is going to care. They are doing a job delivering the mail, they're not the postal police.

I think it is better to let it go. The longer you think about it, the more mad you will get. You are not going to get the closure that you're looking for. Nobody is going to send you a letter saying sorry for stealing from you.

Harsh, but the truth.

[mjaas]

I'm going to send Sulley1234 a postcard, not a letter, with some questions on the message part of the card. Lots of posties read these. Maybe they'll be alerted to keep Sulley's address under observation.

I am on the same boat as you are, angry for being ripped off not by sully but by star lover/winchesterlust, an oldie with lots of positive ratings. But I think there's nothing we can do about it, some people are really heartless. But I believe in karma, what goes around comes around.

[Sally888]

Hey everyone, I am going to put justdoit on the blacklist, I was waiting for their addy, to see if they are the same person.

As for Sulley1234 I have been in discussion with Boo to see if theres anything else we can do. As most of you know I have had a really tough week and while I do care about this issue I haven't had a chance to dedicate myself 100% to it this week.

[Peachykeen2007]

Just wondering why you keep sticking up for this Sulley1234 person???


I ask this because if it was me I wouldn't just LET IT GO and neither should any of the others

No postal worker is going to care. They are doing a job delivering the mail, they're not the postal police.

I think it is better to let it go. The longer you think about it, the more mad you will get. You are not going to get the closure that you're looking for. Nobody is going to send you a letter saying sorry for stealing from you.

Harsh, but the truth.

[Sally888]

I spoke to Boo and if someone wants to organize a complaint to the local police where Sully lives that is fine with us. Meanwhile he is on the blacklist, and I'm pretty sure justdoit2008, is the same user as well. Please refer to the trade list sticky to make sure there isn't tons of pending trades with a novice trader.

This is really unfortunate this happened.

[Sally888]

Just wondering why you keep sticking up for this Sulley1234 person???


I ask this because if it was me I wouldn't just LET IT GO and neither should any of the others

Thats because this user thinks were apparently stupid and can't tell they have 3 accounts. Harsh, is the fact i'm banning their accounts.

[Kyryakos]

Thats because this user thinks were apparently stupid and can't tell they have 3 accounts. Harsh, is the fact i'm banning their accounts.

That is not true.

You banned my account when I have a bunch of outstanding trades for gift cards and I have sent everyone their gift cards and now I am unable to communicate with anyone.

Why am I being banned? Please reinstate my account so that I can finish my trades!!

If I wasn't able to use another computer right now I would have no way of communicating with anyone and might have lost all of my money. Is that how this website works? Banning people without notice when they're in the middle of trades. Maybe smartcanucks should be reported along with the other scammers who use it.

[Sally888]

That is not true.

You banned my account when I have a bunch of outstanding trades for gift cards and I have sent everyone their gift cards and now I am unable to communicate with anyone.

Why am I being banned? Please reinstate my account so that I can finish my trades!!

If I wasn't able to use another computer right now I would have no way of communicating with anyone and might have lost all of my money. Is that how this website works? Banning people without notice when they're in the middle of trades. Maybe smartcanucks should be reported along with the other scammers who use it.

you have three seperate accounts. One was made just to comment on the postal strike. Completely unacceptable to have multiple accounts. Which one out of the now 4 do you want active?

[Sally888]

Star_lover28 and Winchesterlust are the same user, and have been banned. I am very dissapointed at this whole situation. We gave her a second chance and slapping us in the face was her thanks.

Justdoit2008 and Sulley1234 have been banned and are the same user, if you have Justdoit2008 information please let me know.

[mcminsen]

I don't think we'll ever be able to pin down who sulley is. You could go knock on the door of sulley's mailing address and it might be sulley's friend or mother or whoever. The only thing I can think of is trying to get the post office to intercept any mail going to sulley's address and send it back to the original sender. That would be a real shot in the dark, though.

sulley is heartless, as I presume most of the victims are not wealthy.