The Official and ONLY Place to Discuss Negative Trade Experiences + Trade Blacklist

[sdddmd]

I traded with Shigashira on Feb 18th...although I had agreed on a trade only if she were sending out her end first (which she did)...Glad it turned out ok

[sdddmd]

[QUOTE=FallenPixels;5341639]There is another user waiting for a trade from larosa sigh

I'm not too hopeful now

[Insane]

I'm wondering about the whole Red list/Black list. Seems to me that some people on the red list should be on the black. If they aren't communicating, missing trades, ect... how come they get to stay on the red list?

I'm not trying to 2nd guess how you are doing the job. I'm honestly just looking for clarification on the 2 lists.

[luc_anna]

All good, got my end of trade.

[chulo737]

Anyone else waiting on a trade from cammy09. It's only been two weeks, but I have yet to receive my end and she has yet to confirm whether or not she has returned mine. I also noticed another trader posted on her wall regarding a trade. Really hope I get my GC soon.

our trade was confirmed Mar 7, received the gc today....could be my mailman though, my mail is taking an awfully long time to reach me these days

[FallenPixels]

It has been the rule that people are given x amount of time to clear up trades before being placed on the blacklist, I made the redlist to put a hold on traders tht are not so overdue that they belong on the blacklist

In some cases, I just haven't moved them over yet - glenglen never actually traded on SC, in some other cases people have been added to the redlist because their IP matched that of a previous scammer and we asked them to provide proof of being a different person before trading. ISPs do reuse IP addresses so they could be different people

It seems silly to scare newbies with a HUGE blacklist (as you can see from oscarandme's post) when some of them are behind on only one trade but there are issues
In some cases, the person who made the complaint still has to send me info too - I will not blacklist a user without all info

[luc_anna]

our trade was confirmed Mar 7, received the gc today....could be my mailman though, my mail is taking an awfully long time to reach me these days

Good to hear, I was a little worried when I saw someone posting on her wall about a trade. Guess CP is just being really slow with this one.

[momof5boys]

Also curious as to why
IRefuse_2_PayFullPrice

was removed from the do not trade with list.... I still haven't heard from this trader.

I'm wondering about the whole Red list/Black list. Seems to me that some people on the red list should be on the black. If they aren't communicating, missing trades, ect... how come they get to stay on the red list?

I'm not trying to 2nd guess how you are doing the job. I'm honestly just looking for clarification on the 2 lists.

[MDellen]

I confirmed a trade with hugogod at the end of last week but I asked her to send her end first so we'll see if I receive it... I told her I would mail her end off as soon as I received the trade and she said she was ok with that. Kind of glad I didn't send anything now! I'll update if I get it!

Same here, will update if I ever get an envelope but I highly doubt I will.

[Insane]

It has been the rule that people are given x amount of time to clear up trades before being placed on the blacklist, I made the redlist to put a hold on traders tht are not so overdue that they belong on the blacklist

In some cases, I just haven't moved them over yet - glenglen never actually traded on SC, in some other cases people have been added to the redlist because their IP matched that of a previous scammer and we asked them to provide proof of being a different person before trading. ISPs do reuse IP addresses so they could be different people

It seems silly to scare newbies with a HUGE blacklist (as you can see from oscarandme's post) when some of them are behind on only one trade but there are issues
In some cases, the person who made the complaint still has to send me info too - I will not blacklist a user without all info

The only reason I ask is because without addresses, it's impossible to know if the people on the red list have just created a new userid and started all over again.

[FallenPixels]

The people on the redlist are typically still active on the forum
In one case, the person was on vacation, it was a warning she was behind just in case, but as expected, she fixed the issue as soon as she returned

momof5boys, she has has a do not trade added to her itrader account

[2jk19]

I traded with Shigashira on Feb 18th...although I had agreed on a trade only if she were sending out her end first (which she did)...Glad it turned out ok

Same, I traded with her no problem - but she agreed to send her end first and it worked out. Sad to hear there are issues now

[sdddmd]

Negative given to larosa2001

Trade agreement was made on march 1st and I never received my end
sent her numerous PM's without any response until march 28 when she said she had sent out my end on the 1st and was sick with pneumonia. Also said she could not send a replacement for original trade agreement cause coupon was to expire too soon and she would look around with family and friends for "good coupons" And get back to me.....
It is now april 3rd, and I have not heard back from her and she is not answering my PM's

[Stretchthatdollar!]

I also had a trade with her and problem a few months back...said she received my end late, after FPc expired ( though she DID take a photo of a Natrel Baboo FPC in front of my lattest pm so I dunno) I didn't ever receive her end. We agreed to not replace.... But just an FYInot the first time.

Negative given to larosa2001

Trade agreement was made on march 1st and I never received my end
sent her numerous PM's without any response until march 28 when she said she had sent out my end on the 1st and was sick with pneumonia. Also said she could not send a replacement for original trade agreement cause coupon was to expire too soon and she would look around with family and friends for "good coupons" And get back to me.....
It is now april 3rd, and I have not heard back from her and she is not answering my PM's

[sdddmd]

I also had a trade with her and problem a few months back...said she received my end late, after FPc expired ( though she DID take a photo of a Natrel Baboo FPC in front of my lattest pm so I dunno) I didn't ever receive her end. We agreed to not replace.... But just an FYInot the first time.

she finally pm'd me back (very shortly after I left her negative feedback) and said she was just about to make me an offer including an FPC before she saw the feedback... A bit too fishy for me ...